Criteria

The criteria given to reviewers for paper evaluasion are [3]:
1. Relevance to the scope of International Energy Journal
2. Orginality.
3. Engineering/scientific relevance.
4. Doubtful or controvesial arguments.
5. Completeness of the reported work.
6. Adequacy of acknowledgment of the past related work by others, in reference list.
7. Organization and composition of the manuscript, with must have:
• Definition of the objective.
• Justification of the objective.
• Accomplishment of the objective.
• Description of the methode of the study.
• Clear presentation and discustion of the results.
• Validation of the results by others.
• Comparison to the results by others.
• Concise conclusions/recommendations.
• Clarity and good expression in English, and of table and illustrations.
• Appropriate length.


Literature

[3] Anonim, The criteria given to Reviewers for paper evaluasion, retrieved Oktober 28, 2007 from http://203.159.5.16/ PHProot/ RERIC/policy.php